Case Results
Perez Mayoral, P.A. has built a reputation for securing meaningful victories for homeowners and businesses throughout Florida. Our attorneys have successfully obtained favorable judgments, substantial awards, and precedent-setting decisions that protect our clients' rights. These case results highlight our strategic approach and relentless advocacy in difficult property and business disputes.
Disclaimer: The outcome of any legal matter depends on the specific facts and circumstances of each case. Past results do not guarantee or predict similar outcomes in future cases. Any testimonials, case results, verdicts, or settlements presented are for illustrative purposes only and should not be interpreted as a guarantee of a particular result in your case. Every case is different, and results will vary based on the unique legal and factual issues involved.
Close v. Universal Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co.
Following a successful jury trial, Perez Mayoral, P.A. secured a favorable final judgment in the Circuit Court of the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit, Palm Beach County, awarding $195,608.32 in attorney’s fees and costs.
Commercial Condominium Governance and Property Damage
Represented commercial property owner against condominium association in significant breach of governing documents litigation. The case involved substantial property damage that rendered the commercial unit untenable. Following strategic litigation through documentary evidence and expert testimony regarding the association's failures, secured $200,000 settlement including full compensation for property damages and complete attorney fee recovery.
Water Valve Damage
Our client's unit suffered extensive damage after a leaking water valve in the unit above caused a significant downpour of water into their property. The condo association also shared responsibility for the damage due to their failure to maintain properly functioning shut-off valves and ensure qualified personnel were available on-site to address emergencies promptly. We pursued claims against both the upstairs unit owner and the condo association, securing a favorable settlement of $128,000.
Water Damage from Contractor Negligence
Property damage case settled for $85,000. Client sustained water damage to her unit when roofing contractors hired by the HOA to inspect a leak caused even more damage when they accidentally broke the sprinkler system, flooding her unit.
Fire Damage Repairs
Condominium association paid our client $125,000 on the eve of trial for failing to repair common elements damaged by a fire in July 2022. As part of the settlement, the Board of Directors committed to working directly with our client to perform the necessary repairs.
Roof Leak (Broward County)
We successfully resolved a roof leak case in Broward County where the HOA's failure to maintain the roof caused damage to our client's unit, securing a $55,000 settlement for property restoration.
Complex Water Intrusion Case
Complex property damage case with multiple dates of loss spanning over 6 years with no clear cause of water intrusion from a common element. Successfully resolved the case for $115,000 to restore the client's property back to its pre-loss condition. In addition to the monetary amount, the Association agreed to reroute an unsightly condensation line, fill in a reservoir where water had been seeping, treat for termites, replace damaged common elements plumbing, and restore proper water drainage to the balcony.
Multiple Leak Sources (Miami-Dade County)
We secured a $77,000 settlement for a condominium unit owner in Miami-Dade County whose property was damaged by leaks caused by both association maintenance failures and issues originating from another unit within the building.
Condo Roof Leak (Miami Beach)
Roof leak case resulting in substantial settlement for Miami Beach condominium unit owner.
Bathroom Water Damage
Our client's unit sustained water damage affecting both the primary bathroom and an upstairs bathroom area due to association-related leaks. Through diligent advocacy, we secured a $68,000 settlement to fully compensate our client for the extensive water damage.
Property Damage and Water Intrusion
Our client challenged the Association's compliance with multiple water intrusion events spanning many years. Each defendant was responsible for distinct damages to the client's property, and at mediation the case was resolved for $95,000 with each defendant paying their share of the damages caused.
Water Heater Leak
$42,000The client's condo unit had damage to its flooring and drywall due to upstairs neighbor's water heater leak. A pipe connected to the water heater burst and shot water for about an hour. We sued the neighbor and settled for $42,000.
Roofing Project Gone Wrong
Our client suffered extensive water damage when a roofing project performed by the condominium association went terribly wrong. Due to improper work and openings left in the roof, water poured directly into our client's unit through the ceiling. On the eve of trial, the condominium association agreed to settle for $115,000.
Condo Roof Maintenance Failure (Broward County)
We represented a homeowner in a lawsuit against their condominium association for failing to maintain the common elements, specifically the roof. After the association failed to appear in court, we obtained a default judgment and took the case to trial on damages, where the judge awarded our client approximately $60,000. We successfully negotiated a post-verdict settlement of $60,000, nearly the full amount of the court's verdict.
Water Hammer Damage
Through extensive examination of association maintenance records, we discovered that the HOA failed to properly shut off water systems, causing what is known as "water hammer" - resulting in the bursting of multiple water heaters throughout the building. We successfully proved the association's negligence and obtained a $49,000 settlement for our client's unit damage.
Unfair HOA Practices
We secured a $100,000 settlement against a condominium association for its unfair, harassing, selective, and arbitrary enforcement of its governing documents, which severely impacted our client. Through strategic legal advocacy, we achieved a favorable resolution, ensuring our client received just compensation.
Clogged Pipe Damage
The client's condo unit sustained damage to the ceiling, drywall and flooring due to a common element pipe being clogged above his unit. His upstairs neighbor allegedly flushed a towel down the toilet. We sued the neighbor and the association, settling for $80,000.
Seasonal Resident Mold Damage
A seasonal resident's condominium unit suffered extensive mold damage after exterior stucco cracks allowed moisture to penetrate the walls. Our investigation uncovered the Association's own maintenance records revealing a pattern of exterior stucco cracks throughout the building. Faced with compelling documentation from their own maintenance reports on the eve of trial, the Association agreed to a $32,000 settlement.
Building Deficiency Water Damage
Our client experienced significant water damage during a heavy rainstorm when water seeped into their unit through multiple locations. Through thorough investigation and expert analysis, we proved the water intrusion was caused by multiple cracks in the stucco, exterior walls, and foundation—unmaintained common elements the association knew needed repair but failed to address. The association agreed to settle for $85,000.
Multiple Water Damage Sources
Our firm secured a $77,500 settlement for a client whose condominium unit suffered extensive water damage from multiple sources. The case involved claims against both the condominium association for failing to maintain the roof ($57,500) and against upstairs unit owners for leaking sink and plumbing ($20,000). This favorable resolution was achieved without the need for multiple depositions and protracted litigation.
Hurricane Damage Due to Soffit and Eave Negligence
We represented a unit owner whose property was severely damaged when the condominium association failed to properly maintain the soffits and eaves of the building prior to a hurricane. The association's negligence resulted in portions of the roof being compromised during the storm, causing substantial damage to our client's unit. Using expert testimony, we successfully proved the association's breach of maintenance obligations and secured a $57,000 settlement.
Subfloor Maintenance Failure
Our team secured a $95,000 settlement for clients whose condominium unit suffered extensive damage due to the association's failure to maintain subfloors. The neglected maintenance ultimately caused the floors to cave in, resulting in significant property damage and habitability issues.
Common Element Pipe Failures
Our client suffered repeated water damage when the condominium association failed to properly maintain the common element pipes, which constantly leaked into her unit. Within a few months of filing suit, the association quickly agreed to settle for $50,000 rather than face lengthy litigation.
Elevator and Sales Restriction Case
Our clients owned a condo unit on the 10th floor of a building where the only elevator was constantly out of order. The Association rejected their sale due to a restriction on sales within the first year of ownership, despite approving other sales during that period and inconsistent enforcement. We secured an $85,000 settlement after 2 years of contentious litigation.
Stucco Crack Water Damage
Due to cracks in the stucco on the exterior wall of a condo association, rainwater would leak into our client's home causing damage to kitchen walls and cabinetry beyond repair. Despite aggressive resistance from the HOA attorney, we aggressively litigated the case in court. The court ultimately awarded $74,616, covering full repairs and replacement costs, as well as attorneys' fees.
Roof Leak (Pinellas County)
We successfully resolved a condominium roof leak case in Pinellas County, securing a $28,000 settlement for our client's property damage caused by the association's maintenance failures.
Cracked Slab Foundation Damage
Our client's condominium unit sustained structural damage due to a cracked slab foundation, necessitating extensive repairs to all tile flooring throughout the unit. We successfully obtained $80,000 in compensation covering both the necessary repairs and alternative living expenses during the period of restoration work.
Negligent Roof Maintenance
Our client's condominium unit suffered extensive water damage and mold growth due to the association's negligent roof maintenance. During roof repairs, the association left our client's roof exposed without protective tarping during a storm and refused to replace the tarp for several months. We successfully negotiated this substantial settlement on the eve of trial.
Sewage Backup Case
The condominium association's failure to maintain the common element sewer stack resulted in sewage backup into our client's unit. We successfully established the association's breach of maintenance obligations and secured a $45,000 settlement for our client.
Exterior Stucco Cracks and Roof Leaks (Broward County)
We represented a unit owner whose condominium suffered damage due to the association's failure to maintain exterior stucco and roofing systems. Through comprehensive investigation and expert analysis, we established the association's negligence in maintaining these common elements, securing an $85,000 settlement for our client.
Condo Roof Leak Case
The client's condo unit sustained damages to the ceiling, drywall, and flooring due to the Association's failure to maintain the roof above his unit which was leaking every time it rained. Case settled for $50,000.
Stucco and Roof Issues (Broward County)
Similar to other exterior maintenance cases, we secured a $54,000 settlement for a client whose unit was damaged by the association's failure to maintain exterior stucco and roofing systems in Broward County.
Water Bill Reimbursement
Homeowner's Association's failure to maintain common elements caused a water leak that resulted in an elevated water bill that the Association refused to pay. The day before trial, the Association agreed to reimburse our client for the full balance of the water bill, prejudgment interest, and attorney fees and costs in the sum of $41,185.50.
Roof Leak (Miami-Dade County)
We obtained a $50,000 settlement for a condominium roof leak case in Miami-Dade County, ensuring our client received full compensation for property damage caused by the association's maintenance failures.
Fire Damage to Fence
The client's fence was burnt down because a neighbor caused a fire by failing to turn off a candle overnight. We sued the neighbor for the damages and settled for $40,000.
Mold and Water Damage from Sewer Line
We secured a $49,000 settlement for mold and water damage caused by a leaking common element sewer line in Miami-Dade County, Florida, holding the association accountable for their failure to maintain critical infrastructure.
Roof Leak and Stucco Damage (Palm Beach County)
We obtained a $45,000 settlement for a client whose unit was affected by roof leaks and exterior stucco cracks in Palm Beach County, demonstrating the association's failure to maintain critical building envelope systems.
Condo Roof Leak Case
We represented a unit owner whose condo sustained damage from a roof leak that affected multiple areas of the unit. We obtained a $40,000 settlement to cover the necessary repairs to restore the unit.
Condo Roof Leak Case
Roof leak case resulting in settlement for property damage.
Complex Case After Multiple Counsel Withdrawals
In a challenging case where multiple predecessor counsel had withdrawn and were unable to achieve resolution, we successfully obtained a $115,000 settlement for our client, demonstrating our ability to effectively handle complex matters that other firms could not resolve.
Cracked Slab Foundation Damage
Our client's condominium unit sustained structural damage due to a cracked slab foundation, necessitating extensive repairs to all tile flooring throughout the unit. We successfully obtained $80,000 in compensation covering both the necessary repairs and alternative living expenses during the period of restoration work.
Multiple Leak Sources (Miami-Dade County)
We secured a $77,000 settlement for a condominium unit owner in Miami-Dade County whose property was damaged by leaks caused by both association maintenance failures and issues originating from another unit within the building.
Bathroom Water Damage
Our client's unit sustained water damage affecting both the primary bathroom and an upstairs bathroom area due to association-related leaks. Through diligent advocacy, we secured a $68,000 settlement to fully compensate our client for the extensive water damage.
Roof Leak (Broward County)
We successfully resolved a roof leak case in Broward County where the HOA's failure to maintain the roof caused damage to our client's unit, securing a $55,000 settlement for property restoration.
Stucco and Roof Issues (Broward County)
Similar to other exterior maintenance cases, we secured a $54,000 settlement for a client whose unit was damaged by the association's failure to maintain exterior stucco and roofing systems in Broward County.
Water Hammer Damage
Through extensive examination of association maintenance records, we discovered that the HOA failed to properly shut off water systems, causing what is known as "water hammer" - resulting in the bursting of multiple water heaters throughout the building. We successfully proved the association's negligence and obtained a $49,000 settlement for our client's unit damage.
Roof Leak and Stucco Damage (Palm Beach County)
We obtained a $45,000 settlement for a client whose unit was affected by roof leaks and exterior stucco cracks in Palm Beach County, demonstrating the association's failure to maintain critical building envelope systems.
Full Compensation for Damages and Attorney Fees – Retired Vietnam War Veteran
We represented a retired Vietnam War combat veteran whose condominium unit and windows sustained damage when the association's landscaping contractors repeatedly threw rocks into his home, causing cracks in windows and other property damage. Despite the association's initial denial of responsibility, through a series of strategic demand letters and enforcement actions, we compelled both the association and landscaping contractor to pay for all damages to the windows and unit, plus full compensation for our client's attorney fees.
Complete Defense Victory – Condo Association Lawsuit
Perez Mayoral, P.A. successfully defended our client, a condominium unit owner, in a lawsuit brought by the condominium association alleging property damage caused by the owner's appliances. At the close of the plaintiff's case, we secured a directed verdict, with the Court ruling that the association failed to present sufficient evidence to support its claims. Our client also countersued and received a settlement for his damages.
Unit Owner Granted Entitlement to Recover Attorney’s Fees
After successfully defending our client in a jury trial involving unsupported claims by the Association regarding a water leak allegedly originating from his unit, we also defeated the Association's objection to our client's motion for prevailing party attorneys' fees. The Court held that our client's counterclaim clearly placed the parties on notice regarding fee entitlement.
Federal Court Defense – Complete Dismissal of $1MM+ Claims
Secured complete dismissal in federal litigation where our client faced multiple promissory note claims exceeding one million dollars from a real estate investment company. Through comprehensive discovery and prepared summary judgment arguments, our litigation strategy compelled the plaintiff to voluntarily dismiss all claims with zero financial liability to our client.
Defense Victory in $5MM+ Real Estate Investment Fraud Allegations
Defended real estate development company against claims by purported investor alleging multi-million dollar capital contributions and ownership interest in commercial property. After implementing aggressive discovery strategy that exposed fatal evidentiary deficiencies, secured complete dismissal of all claims.
Full Dismissal of Unsubstantiated Financial Claims
Represented developer of large-scale multi-family project against claims alleging undocumented loans and demanding equitable liens against the development. Through strategic motion practice and discovery, secured dismissal of all claims, preserving our client's substantial equity position in the development.
International Corporate Control Dispute – $10MM+ Asset Portfolio
Resolved deadlocked international litigation involving multiple commercial entities across U.S. and South American jurisdictions after previous representation by AmLaw 100 firm had failed to advance the case. Litigation involved competing ownership claims across multiple corporate entities and commercial real estate holdings valued at tens of millions of dollars. Within months, secured favorable settlement including structured division of substantial international assets.
Multi-Million Dollar Investment Agreement Dispute
Represented corporate client in high-value litigation concerning alleged breaches of a multi-million dollar investment agreement. Our litigation strategy and negotiation approach resulted in resolution at a fraction of the claimed damages, fully preserving our client's capital position and business operations.
Multi-Jurisdictional Insurance Proceeds Recovery
Resolved complex insurance litigation spanning multiple states that previous counsel had been unable to advance for years. Within months of assuming representation, secured complete victory against both a national insurance carrier and lender, resulting in full recovery of six-figure insurance benefits and complete attorney fee reimbursement.
Commercial Fraud Litigation in Merchant Services Dispute
Represented corporate client against sophisticated business-to-business fraud involving substantial merchandise and systematic credit card chargebacks. Litigation resulted in financial recovery and established protective protocols for our client's future commercial transactions.
High-Value Land Acquisition Dispute
Litigated dispute involving purchase and sale agreement for multi-million dollar commercial land parcel. Structured negotiation strategy that preserved transaction timeline while securing favorable terms for our client's significant real estate acquisition.
Corporate Asset Misappropriation and Partnership Dissolution
Litigated corporate governance dispute involving executive-level misconduct and misappropriation of company assets. Case required forensic financial analysis, complex ownership tracing, and strategic asset recovery proceedings, resulting in equitable business dissolution and protection of our client's capital interests.
Federal Court International Supply Chain Litigation
Led federal litigation for South American agricultural supplier against Florida distribution company. Secured judicial determinations on critical cross-border contract enforcement issues related to international purchase and shipping agreements, culminating in structured repayment program.
Restrictive Covenant Enforcement in Hospitality Industry
Represented ATM service provider in restrictive covenant litigation against regional hotel chain. Strategic injunctive approach protected our client's exclusive service territory and preserved valuable commercial relationships within the competitive hospitality sector.
Attorney’s Fee Award Upheld
Universal Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co. v. Close, 376 So. 3d 14 (Fla. 4th DCA 2023) Perez Mayoral, P.A. successfully upheld a $195,608.32 attorney's fee award in the Fourth District Court of Appeal, affirming the trial court's determination of reasonable hours and rates under the lodestar method in an insurance dispute case.
Writ of Prohibition Obtained
Gratz v. 1750 James Condo. Ass'n, Inc Perez Mayoral, P.A. successfully obtained a writ of prohibition from the Third District Court of Appeal, resulting in the disqualification of the trial judge due to apparent partiality in a lawsuit between a homeowner and their condominium association. This significant appellate achievement was detailed in the Daily Business Review.
Air Rights Contract Challenge
We represented a unit owner in litigation against the condominium association challenging the Association's attempted renewal of a contract with a Miami-based developer for the purchase of air rights to property adjacent to the condominium. The proposed transaction threatened to materially diminish the property values of individual condominium units. Through strategic legal advocacy and formal demand correspondence, we compelled the Association to submit the contract renewal to a properly noticed unit owner vote in accordance with the governing documents.
Storage Unit Ownership Rights Protection
We successfully defended a unit owner against the condominium association's attempt to divest our client of storage units appurtenant to his condominium unit. The Association's claim was predicated on alleged ambiguities within the declaration of condominium and the original purchase and sale agreement. Through vigorous advocacy and legal analysis of the governing documents, we secured the Association's agreement to cease all efforts to dispossess our client of his lawfully owned storage units.
Florida Statute 718.113 EV Charging Station Compliance
Our client initiated proceedings against the condominium association for violations of Florida Statutes Section 718.113(8)-(9), which govern the installation and maintenance of electric vehicle charging stations in condominium properties. The Association's non-compliance included failures in proper metering protocols, maintenance responsibilities, insurance coverage requirements, and recordkeeping obligations. The matter was resolved through settlement agreement requiring the Association to implement compliant procedures for all charging station operations and to properly allocate charging station assignments in accordance with statutory requirements.
Common Element Maintenance and Fee Recovery
We represented a unit owner whose property sustained water damage due to the condominium association's breach of its maintenance obligations regarding common element condensation lines. The Association's failure to properly maintain these common elements resulted in backup and flooding that damaged our client's hardwood flooring. Through litigation, we secured full recovery of our client's attorney's fees and costs previously paid to predecessor counsel who had been unable to resolve the matter, plus additional monetary recovery sufficient to restore the damaged property to its pre-loss condition.
Successful Defense Against Illegal Leasing Restrictions
We successfully opposed an association's enforcement action attempting to implement leasing restrictions that would have prohibited our client from leasing her investment property and forced her onto a waiting list. Through vigorous legal advocacy, we established that the association's newly imposed rule was illegal under Florida law and compelled the association to rescind all enforcement actions, allowing our client to continue leasing her unit without restriction.
Airbnb Rights Protection Under Florida Statute
We represented a unit owner against a condominium association that attempted to implement new rules prohibiting Airbnb rentals. Since our client had been operating an Airbnb rental prior to the association's rule change, we successfully demonstrated that the association's actions violated Florida statutes protecting existing rental operations. The association was compelled to rescind the restrictive rule, preserving our client's established rental business.
Fair Housing Act Victory in Sale Approval Dispute
We successfully challenged a condominium association's attempt to deny the sale of a unit to a prospective buyer based on a federal conviction from 30 years prior. Utilizing Fair Housing Act protections and demonstrating the discriminatory nature of the association's actions, we compelled the association to approve the sale, ensuring our client could complete their real estate transaction without unlawful interference.